Innovative Take-Home Cuisine & Exceptional Full-Service Catering


Thanksgiving is right around the corner and we have everything you need a la carte for pick up on Wednesday November 22nd. TURKEY, Roasted Butternut Squash SOUP with Cider Cream, Mushroom Madeira Soup, Cranberry Orange Compote, and GRAVY!
In addition – STUFFINGS Bread Stuffing, Corn Bread and Sausage Stuffing, Mashed Sweet Potato Gratin and so many more. Plus BREADS and PIES!
See our complete Thanksgiving A La Carte Menu. And here is our Christmas & Holiday Menu too!

You have invited us into your homes and allowed us to cater your weddings, baby showers and anniversary parties. We’ve prepared your holiday feasts and your game day treats. We’ve been to your business lunch meetings and corporate grand opening events.

You’ve braved the cold winter days for our soup of the day, Mediterranean veggies, dinner entrees, Anne’s salted caramels and . . . let’s not forget the simple pleasures of our chocolate chip cookies. When you stop in, make sure to say hello and stock up on our take-home prepared foods for lunch or dinner tonight! Visit us on FACEBOOK And don’t forget for special dietary needs, we have a full variety of gluten-free foods at Plum street gourmet and our Healthy Plates program.

Too busy to cook…get home late? But want to eat healthy and not the usual take-out again? Let us help you free up your time, by preparing healthy, fresh foods for you, all ready to go, just heat and serve! Homemade and delicious!

Soup Calendar Plum Street GourmetHealthy Plates


Thank you for voting Plum Street Gourmet Susquehanna Magazine’s Best Caterer AGAIN in Lancaster 2017!

Holiday Hours:
Wed Nov 22 | Open 8am-7pm – Thanksgiving pick ups!
Fri Nov 24 | Open 8am-7pm
Sat Nov 25 | 9am-3pm
Sat Dec 23 | 9am-3pm – Holiday pick ups!
Sat Dec 30 | 9am-3pm – Holiday pick ups!
Plum Street will be CLOSED FOR THE HOLIDAYS on NOVEMBER 23 | DECEMBER 24, 25, 26 and 31 | JANUARY 1 and 2

“Food was delish and tons of compliments! They partied like no tomorrow!!! Thanks again and I look forward to working with you and your team again!! You are always on my referral list!” Best, Lori

We love what we doAnd we love that you love what we do too! Thank you for your business over these incredible 30+ years.
Plum Street originally opened on Plum Street in Lancaster in 1984.
Lori Hemphill, Catering Director  lorihemphillplum@gmail.com

EVERYONE was over the moon! If we have any other events – we know who  to call! Katy

A group of us were just discussing how impressed we were with the Plum Street.  I feel, it’s a given your food is going to be wonderful and presented uniquely but what impressed us the most was how your staff went out of their way to pack up leftovers and clean-up.  Great group of people! Brad